| Year | Var# | R. | Description | Grade | Cert# | Price | Date | Auction Name | Lot# |
| [1828] | [123] | [5+] | [ R5 5th Ed. ] | [13/K] | [ R5+ BHNC ] | [ 5th Ed. CC: 64,63,58,55,55 ] | |||
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk, *AU58, PL, wiped | 50 | 3,995 | 01/13 | S. Downey Fixed Price List | FPL | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk or tracks | 45 | 4,370 | 11/02 | Bowers&M (Logan/Steinberg) | 2577 | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | Kahn,Irons,Link,Semi-PL,PCGS | 40 | 3,500 | 04/21 | S. Downey Fixed Price List | FPL | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk, A-Det, *cleaned | 40 | 1,200 | 03/19 | S. Downey Fixed Price List | FPL | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk, P.92, *cleaned | 40 | 27455540 | 3,120 | 02/18 | Heritage 1272 (Internet) | 8123 |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk, Ex Meyer, ANACS | 40 | 4,000 | 05/10 | S. Downey Fixed Price List | FPL | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk or tracks, *harsh cln | 40 | 5078796-068 | 2,990 | 01/06 | Heritage 390 (Reiver-Dallas) | 23096 |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk or tracks, *lt wipe,dig | 40 | 2,675 | 11/05 | S. Downey Fixed Price List | FPL | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk or tracks, *cleaned | 40 | 4,250 | 11/04 | Private Treaty n/a | ||
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk (now PCGS XF40) | 40 | 3,220 | 03/01 | Bowers&M (LaRiviere, Part 2) | 1715 | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk or tracks, ANACS | 40 | 4,810 | 11/99 | Downey Mail Bid #24 (Farley) | 181 | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk or tracks, *ft hrlns | 35 | 1,898 | 02/04 | Coin Galleries Mail Bid | 1581 | |
| 1828 | 123 | 7- | No rim brk or tracks, PCGS | 4 | 31435255 | 764 | 03/15 | Stack's-Bowers 6065 (Baltimor) | 5529 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | Finest, Ex Hain #1371, PCGS | 64 | 12,124 | 07/08 | Downey (Meyer-Sel. Rarities) | 40 | |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | Ex Alpine FPL(10/04), PCGS | 55 | 6680535 | 6,600 | 08/15 | Downey MB #41 (ANA-Chicago) | 69 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | (unattributed), PCGS | 50 | not available | 2,128 | 12/12 | Teletrade 3400 219 | 8 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | Ex DMB51 #70, PCGS(CAC) | 45 C | 31969173 | not sold | 01/22 | Downey Mail Bid #53 (Osborne) | 93 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | PCGS(CAC) | 45 C | 31969173 | 3,520 | 02/21 | Downey Mail Bid #51 | 70 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | VLDS(lapped), PCGS | 45 | 38264021 | 3,840 | 11/19 | Stack's-Bowers (Baltimore) | 7169 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | NGC (Skidaway) | 45 | 3808688-005 | 3,290 | 02/15 | Heritage 1218 (PNG-Dallas) | 3789 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | PCGS | 40 | 30694753 | 901 | 12/21 | Heritage 60233(Founding Fathr) | 91431 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | (as O.123, R7), P.92, *cleaned | 40 | 29473133 | 1,110 | 11/20 | Heritage 1321 (Internet) | 7082 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | VLDS (lapped), PCGS | 40 | 20330898 | 1,860 | 08/19 | Heritage 1298 (ANA-Chicago) | 3483 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | PCGS | 40 | 34480053 | 2,640 | 01/18 | Heritage 1271 (FUN-Tampa) | 3686 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | LDS, ANACS | 40 | 3,681 | 01/12 | Stu Keen Fixed Price List | FPL | |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | PCGS, *lightly hairlined | 40 | 15465660 | 2,990 | 01/11 | Heritage 1151 (FUN-Tampa) | 3726 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | PCGS, *rim nick at 4:30 rev | 25 | 36149047 | 1,740 | 09/19 | Heritage 1299 (Long Beach) | 3488 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | Ex Downey(07/02) #19, *hrlns | 25 | 2,178 | 04/12 | Downey #35 (CSNS-Bluegrass) | 116 | |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | P.92, *cleaning | 20 | 32856955 | 1,639 | 01/16 | Downey MB #42 (FUN-Tampa) | 66 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | P-Gen.98, *damage/tooling | 20 | 27382685 | 499 | 05/13 | Stack’s-B 190 (ANA-N'Orleans) | 359 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | PCGS | 15 | 26287367 | 1,200 | 02/18 | Heritage 1272 (Internet) | 8124 |
| 1828 | 123a | 5+ | P.97, *environmental dmg | 8 | 33128289 | 264 | 08/22 | Great Collect (D.S. Registry) | 1186053 |